Best Open-Flame Grills Like the Blackstone for Backyard Cooking: Top Picks, Honest Comparisons, and What Actually Matters
Our take
The Blackstone Bronco Open Flame Grill is the top pick for backyard cooks who want purpose-built open-fire performance at an accessible price — its height-adjustable grate system and charcoal-forward design deliver direct-heat control that gas and hybrid alternatives cannot match. For buyers who want maximum versatility across fuel types and cooking styles, the KUDU Open Fire Grill is the strongest alternative, though it carries a substantial price premium. If the budget is the primary constraint or the household relies on a gas-based setup, the Camp Chef Explorer Griddle and Open Flame Combo covers more ground for less money.
Who it's for
- The Steak-First Backyard Cook — someone who prioritizes crust, char, and direct-fire flavor above everything else and wants a dedicated open-flame setup rather than a gas grill that approximates a sear.
- The Outdoor Entertainer Upgrading from a Kettle — someone who has outgrown a standard charcoal kettle and wants height adjustability, higher capacity, and more precise fire management without moving to pellet or gas.
- The Technique-Driven Pitmaster — someone drawn to wood-fire and live-coal cooking methods — gaucho-style grilling, Argentine asado, charcoal-seared smash burgers — who wants equipment that actively supports fire management rather than abstracting it away.
- The Grill-and-Griddle Consolidator — someone who currently runs both a flat-top griddle and a charcoal kettle and wants to simplify into a single platform that handles both without a significant compromise on either.
Who should look elsewhere
Buyers whose primary goal is low-and-slow smoking will find open-flame grills more frustrating than useful — a dedicated offset, kamado, or pellet grill is a better match for that use case. Apartment dwellers and anyone subject to strict HOA rules or balcony fire codes should also look elsewhere, as open-flame charcoal and wood setups are prohibited in many residential contexts.
Pros
- The Bronco's height-adjustable grate enables direct fire management — raising or lowering food relative to the coals — that gas grills are structurally incapable of replicating.
- Open-flame charcoal cooking produces the Maillard reaction depth and smoke character that consistently sets the flavor benchmark in owner communities, particularly for red meat and bone-in cuts.
- The Bronco's charcoal basket is engineered to support lump charcoal and wood chunks within the same cook, giving fuel flexibility without requiring any configuration changes.
- Significantly lower entry price than premium open-fire alternatives like the KUDU, making serious live-fire cooking accessible without the premium outlay.
- Modular grate accessories — cast iron plancha inserts, spit attachments — expand the cooking repertoire without requiring a second unit.
- The barrel-style cooking chamber provides enough real estate for whole chickens, multiple racks of ribs, or a full brisket flat alongside an active searing station.
Cons
- Open-flame charcoal cooking demands active fire management — this is not a set-and-forget format, and buyers expecting pellet-grill convenience will be disappointed.
- The Bronco is charcoal-only with no gas backup option, which makes it impractical as a sole grill for quick weeknight cooks.
- Executing consistent multi-zone temperature management requires practice and attention to fuel staging — the learning curve is meaningfully steeper than gas.
- Ash cleanup after charcoal and wood sessions is more involved than maintaining a gas or pellet grill, particularly without a removable ash pan.
- The Bronco's open-barrel format is less efficient for sustained low-and-slow indirect cooking than a dedicated kamado or offset smoker.
- Wind exposure affects open-flame performance more than it affects enclosed cooking systems — site selection matters and exposed locations compound the challenge.
How it compares
KUDU Open Fire Grill
The KUDU is the premium benchmark in this category. Its four swing-out grate arms allow independent height and angle adjustment per cooking zone, its South African open-fire heritage shows in its engineering, and its construction quality is consistently cited as exceptional in owner communities. The barrier is price: the KUDU commands roughly double the cost of the Bronco at time of publication. That premium is genuinely earned — but only for cooks who will actively use multi-zone live-fire technique, cook large-format proteins for groups regularly, and treat open-fire cooking as a central part of their outdoor cooking identity. For most backyard cooks, the Bronco covers the core use case without the additional spend.
Oklahoma Joe's Firecraft Series Barrel Grill
The Firecraft Series applies Oklahoma Joe's offset-smoker construction heritage to an open-flame barrel format, and the result shows: the hinged firebox and calibrated air vent system reflect genuine understanding of fire management. Build quality benchmarks competitively against the Bronco at similar price points, and side-access fueling makes mid-cook charcoal additions less disruptive. The key functional limitation is the fixed grate height — temperature management relies on airflow control rather than physical positioning of food relative to the fire, which is a different technique and a less direct form of heat adjustment. A strong pick for buyers already comfortable with barrel or offset cooking who want open-flame capability without relearning a new platform.
Camp Chef Explorer Griddle + Open Flame Gas Grill Combo
The Camp Chef Explorer is a fundamentally different value proposition — gas-primary, not charcoal-primary, pairing a flat-top griddle surface with open-grate gas burner zones. For buyers who want griddle and direct-flame capability from a single propane setup, it is one of the most practical dual-mode solutions available. The tradeoff is a lower flavor ceiling: propane open-flame cooking lacks the aromatic smoke character and fat-on-coal complexity of the Bronco or KUDU. A strong pick for households that cook varied menus and prioritize convenience and fuel consistency over live-fire authenticity. The key framing for cross-shoppers: the Camp Chef Explorer and the Bronco are not competing for the same cook — they represent different philosophies about what outdoor cooking should feel like.
Weber Spirit E-425 Four-Burner Gas Grill
The Weber Spirit E-425 is not an open-flame grill in any meaningful sense — it is included here as the reference point for buyers actively comparing the open-flame category against traditional gas. Weber's multi-zone gas control and decades of reliability data are well-established, but the Spirit cannot produce open-fire char, live-coal aromatics, or the heat intensity that direct-fire cooking delivers. In this context, it is a niche pick: the right choice for buyers who prioritize ease of use, gas convenience, and Weber's service network over open-fire performance. Choosing between the Spirit and the Bronco is not a hardware decision — it is a decision about which cooking philosophy you actually want to live with.
Pit Boss 850 Pellet Grill with Open Flame Zone
The Pit Boss 850 features a slide-and-grill direct-flame access zone that partially addresses the searing limitations of standard pellet grills. It is a genuine niche pick for buyers whose primary use case is low-and-slow smoking, with occasional searing requirements on the side — the blend is useful for that specific profile. However, the open-flame zone on the 850 is a narrow cooking surface relative to a dedicated open-fire grill, and the pellet system's flavor profile differs from charcoal or wood-fire cooking in ways that experienced cooks reliably notice. Not the right tool when direct-fire cooking is the primary goal rather than an afterthought.
Why Open-Flame Grills Matter: The Honest Case for Direct Heat Cooking
The open-flame category exists because gas grills, pellet grills, and even most charcoal kettle setups create managed distance between the cook and the fire. Grates sit at a fixed height above a burner or coal bed, cooking surface temperature is controlled indirectly through vents or dials, and the cook has limited ability to modulate heat intensity mid-cook without adding or removing fuel. Open-flame grills invert that relationship. The fire is the primary tool, and the cook manages its output directly — raising or lowering the grate relative to the coals, repositioning wood splits to build or redistribute heat zones, or letting a fire settle for a gentler finish pass. The flavor outcomes are distinct and well-documented in owner communities: the Maillard reaction develops more aggressively under higher radiant heat, fat dripping onto live coals generates aromatic smoke at the point of impact rather than in a distant drip tray, and the thermal mass of quality lump charcoal or hardwood holds and radiates heat in a way that gas flames do not. For ribeyes, whole fish, vegetables with intentional char, bone-in chicken, and lamb cuts that benefit from live-fire crust development, owner communities consistently report that open-flame setups produce results that enclosed gas and pellet systems approximate but don't fully replicate. The honest case is not that open-flame cooking is better for everything — it is that it is significantly better for a specific set of outcomes that matter to a specific type of cook. Understanding that distinction upfront is what separates a purchase that transforms how you cook outdoors from one that collects ash between occasional uses.
Blackstone Bronco vs. the Field: What Makes It Stand Out (and Where It Falls Short)
The Blackstone Bronco's defining feature is its height-adjustable grate system, which allows the cook to raise or lower the cooking surface relative to the charcoal bed in discrete increments. This is not a convenience feature — it is the functional core of live-fire cooking technique. Owner feedback patterns consistently identify the grate adjustment mechanism as the primary differentiator from barrel-style grills with fixed grates, where managing temperature requires manipulating airflow vents rather than the physical relationship between food and fire. Changing grate height mid-cook is an active decision with an immediate effect; adjusting a bottom vent is a passive one with a delayed result. The Bronco's barrel format provides a large cooking area by open-flame standards, and its charcoal basket is engineered to support both lump charcoal and wood chunks without the fuel management issues that plague open-bottom designs in wind. Owner feedback on the grate adjustment mechanism is consistently positive, with no significant reported pattern of the locking system failing under cooking load. Where the Bronco falls short is equally worth stating plainly. It is a charcoal-only system with no gas backup option — a real limitation for households that need the grill to cover weeknight convenience as well as weekend performance. Its open-barrel design is less thermally efficient for sustained low-and-slow indirect cooking than a kamado or offset; holding low temperatures requires more active fuel management than beginners typically anticipate. And the Bronco's place in the Blackstone product lineup should be understood clearly: it shares a brand name with Blackstone's flat-top propane griddles but shares none of their operational DNA. Buyers expecting griddle-style ease of use will find the Bronco a different proposition entirely. This is a serious piece of equipment, not a beginner grill with a familiar name.
The Competition: KUDU, Oklahoma Joe's Firecraft, and Traditional Gas/Charcoal Hybrids
The KUDU Open Fire Grill originates from South African open-fire cooking tradition and brings an engineering approach that differs fundamentally from the American barrel-grill format. Its four swing-out grate arms allow independent height and angle adjustment per cooking zone, enabling the cook to manage multiple proteins at different temperatures simultaneously — a meaningful practical advantage when cooking for groups with varied preferences or protein thicknesses. KUDU's construction quality is frequently cited in owner communities as exceptional, with heavy-gauge steel and heat retention characteristics that outperform most competitors at equivalent capacity. The premium price is the genuine barrier: KUDU commands significantly more than the Bronco at time of publication, and its additional capability only delivers full value to cooks who actively use multi-zone live-fire technique. For a casual backyard cook who grills a few steaks on weekends, the premium is difficult to justify on honest terms. Oklahoma Joe's Firecraft Series arrives with brand credibility earned in the offset smoker category and applies that knowledge to a barrel-format open-flame grill. Its calibrated air vent system and hinged firebox access reflect a genuine understanding of fire management, and the build quality benchmarks competitively against the Bronco at comparable price points. The primary functional limitation is the fixed grate height, which shifts all temperature management responsibility to airflow control. That is a workable technique — it is simply a less direct and less immediately responsive form of heat adjustment than the Bronco's vertical positioning system. A strong pick for cooks already fluent in charcoal who want an open-flame upgrade without rebuilding their technique from the ground up. The Camp Chef Explorer Griddle and Open Flame Combo occupies a different category conceptually. It is a gas-primary system with a griddle surface and open-grate burner zone, engineered for versatility rather than live-fire purity. For buyers who want to cover flat-top breakfast cooking and direct-flame searing from a single propane unit, it is one of the more practical solutions on the market. The flavor ceiling is lower than charcoal or wood-fire setups, but the convenience gap is substantial — no ash, instant ignition, and consistent output regardless of ambient conditions or wind. The key insight for anyone cross-shopping the Explorer and the Bronco: these products are not competing for the same cook. They reflect different answers to the question of what outdoor cooking is fundamentally for.
Open Flame vs. Griddle vs. Traditional Grill: When to Use Each
The decision between open-flame, flat-top griddle, and traditional gas or charcoal is a decision about which cooking outcomes matter most — not a ranking of formats by objective quality. Here is the honest framework: Open-flame grills are the right tool when char, crust development, and live-fire smoke are the primary objectives. Ribeyes, lamb chops, whole fish, bone-in chicken thighs, thick-cut vegetables, and anything that benefits from intense radiant heat and aromatic fat-on-coal smoke belong in this category. The tradeoff is active fire management, longer setup, and a less forgiving window for timing errors. Flat-top griddles — the traditional Blackstone territory — are the right tool for high-volume, surface-contact cooking where even heat across a large area matters more than char. Smash burgers, breakfast spreads, thin proteins, stir-fry, and large batches of shellfish are flat-top territory. The griddle is faster to clean, more forgiving on timing, and more efficient at scale — but it produces no live-fire smoke character and limited crust depth compared to direct flame. Traditional gas grills with grates occupy the practical middle — grill marks, some char development, broad weeknight versatility. They represent the highest convenience option for the widest range of regular cooking tasks, but they concede flavor ceiling to open-flame setups and surface versatility to flat-tops. The synthesis that no spec sheet provides: most buyers trying to choose between these formats are actually choosing between cooking frequency and cooking intensity. If you cook outdoors three or four nights a week, a gas grill or griddle wins on convenience and will likely produce better real-world results simply by being used more often. If you cook outdoors once or twice a week and those sessions genuinely matter — weekend entertainment, intentional meals, cooking as an event in itself — an open-flame setup pays off in ways that gas and griddle formats don't. Be honest about which cook you are before you commit to which tool.
Top Picks for 2026: Product Breakdown and Performance Summary
Blackstone Bronco Open Flame Grill — Top Pick The Bronco's height-adjustable grate is the most direct implementation of live-fire technique available at its price point. Owner feedback consistently identifies the adjustment mechanism as reliable under extended use, with no significant reported pattern of the height locking system failing under cooking load. The charcoal basket accommodates both lump and briquette fuel, with owners reporting burn characteristics that support multi-hour cook sessions without constant attention. Cook surface area is competitive for the category. Primary owner criticism centers on the learning curve for temperature management and the absence of any gas or pellet hybrid option — both honest limitations that should inform the purchase decision. KUDU Open Fire Grill — Strong Pick KUDU's multi-arm grate system is the most flexible live-fire cooking setup in this comparison field. Owner communities experienced in gaucho and Argentine asado cooking consistently describe the KUDU as the closest available analog to traditional South American open-fire rigs in a backyard-legal format. Construction quality reports are uniformly positive across owner communities. The premium is real and substantial; buyers should honestly assess whether they will use the multi-zone adjustability before purchasing. Oklahoma Joe's Firecraft Series Barrel Grill — Strong Pick Credible construction and genuine fire management engineering in a barrel-grill format. Best suited to buyers already comfortable with charcoal who want an open-flame upgrade from a standard kettle. Fixed grate height is the key functional distinction versus the Bronco — not a flaw, but a technique difference that matters depending on how actively you want to manage your fire. Camp Chef Explorer Griddle + Open Flame Combo — Strong Pick The most practical dual-mode unit in the comparison set for buyers who want griddle and direct-flame capability from a single propane system. Trades live-fire authenticity for fuel consistency and operational simplicity. A strong choice for households cooking varied menus that span breakfast griddle sessions and direct-flame dinners from the same unit. Pit Boss 850 Pellet Grill with Open Flame Zone — Niche Pick The correct choice for buyers whose primary use case is smoking, with occasional searing needs on the side. The slide-and-grill direct-flame zone is functional but limited in surface area. Not suited as a primary open-flame tool. Weber Spirit E-425 — Niche Pick in this context Best-in-class gas grill with a strong reliability track record. Included as the gas grill reference point for buyers cross-shopping categories, not as an open-flame competitor. If you are comparing the Spirit to the Bronco, you are deciding between cooking philosophies — not between two versions of the same thing.
What to Look for in an Open-Flame Grill: Grates, Heat Control, and Build Quality
Grate Adjustability: The single most consequential mechanical feature in an open-flame grill. Fixed grates shift all temperature management to airflow control, which works but limits responsiveness and immediacy. Height-adjustable grates — like the Bronco's — allow the cook to modulate heat intensity directly by changing the physical distance between food and fire. Look for adjustment mechanisms that can be operated safely while cooking, without requiring tools or full-hand contact with hot metal components under load. Cooking Surface Material: Cast iron grates retain heat exceptionally well and build seasoning over time, but require more maintenance than stainless steel. Stainless steel grates are lower maintenance and corrosion-resistant, but carry less thermal mass. For live-fire searing, cast iron is commonly preferred by experienced cooks for its heat retention and sear character. Many units offer both options or allow aftermarket swaps — worth confirming before purchase. Firebox Construction and Fuel Access: Evaluate how easy it is to add fuel mid-cook without disrupting the grate setup. Side-access fireboxes and hinged charcoal baskets are meaningfully better than designs that require full grate removal to reach the coal bed. Adding wood chunks during a long cook while managing proteins actively on the grate is a real operational scenario — the design should account for it. Air Vent Quality and Placement: Vents that stick, warp, or develop gaps after a season of thermal cycling undermine temperature control significantly. Look for smooth-operating vents in materials that maintain fit over repeated high-temperature use. Bottom vents supply oxygen; top vents manage exhaust. Units with multiple bottom vent positions give more nuanced control at low temperatures — a detail that matters for indirect cooking. Steel Gauge and Weld Quality: Heavier-gauge steel holds heat more consistently and resists warping over extended high-temperature use. Weld quality is difficult to assess from spec sheets — a pattern of owner reports describing weld cracking or separation after one or two seasons is a meaningful warning sign worth searching for in owner communities before purchasing. The KUDU and Oklahoma Joe's Firecraft both benchmark well on construction quality based on available owner feedback. The Bronco receives generally positive construction marks at its price point, with occasional reports of paint discoloration at peak heat areas — a cosmetic issue that owner feedback does not connect to any structural integrity concern.
Accessories That Transform Your Open-Flame Setup
Cast Iron Plancha or Griddle Insert: A cast iron flat-top insert that sits on the grate over direct coals gives an open-flame grill genuine flat-top capability without a separate unit. Particularly useful for smash burgers, eggs, or high-heat vegetable searing where direct grate contact isn't ideal. Many aftermarket options are available in dimensions compatible with the Bronco and KUDU grate systems — confirm fit before purchasing. Gaucho-Style Rotisserie Attachment: A motorized or hand-crank spit that mounts across the fire bowl enables whole chicken, lamb leg, and large-format rotisserie cooking over live coals. Slow rotation over an open fire produces results that oven rotisseries and gas rotisserie setups don't replicate. Attachment system compatibility varies across grill models — verify before purchasing any third-party spit. Chimney Starter: Not optional. A quality chimney starter is the correct method for lighting lump charcoal for open-flame cooking. Lighter fluid introduces chemical compounds that persist in the coal bed and carry into the food during the cook. Choose a chimney with a capacity appropriate to the Bronco's or KUDU's coal bed — undersized chimneys require multiple loads and extend setup time unnecessarily. Long-Handle Grilling Tools: Open-flame cooking over direct charcoal runs significantly hotter at the cook's hands and face than gas grilling. Standard-length tongs and spatulas place hands too close to the fire zone during active management. Long-handle tools — specifically tongs with reliable locking mechanisms — are a practical safety necessity, not an optional upgrade. Infrared Surface Thermometer: Cooking-surface temperature in open-flame setups varies significantly across the grate, especially during multi-zone fires. An infrared thermometer allows quick surface mapping before food placement — a technique consistently used by experienced open-fire cooks to manage varied protein thicknesses and doneness targets across a full grate load. More useful than a dome thermometer for this cooking style. Dry Fuel Storage: Covered storage for charcoal and wood is an underrated setup consideration. Wet lump charcoal and waterlogged wood splits produce poor combustion and excessive acrid smoke during ignition that can affect food flavor. A covered storage bin or a dedicated dry space for fuel is a worthwhile investment for anyone using an open-flame setup through multiple seasons.
Maintenance, Safety, and Year-Round Storage
Ash Management: Ash left in the fire bowl retains moisture, accelerates corrosion of the steel floor, and restricts airflow through bottom vents in subsequent sessions. After each cook, once the grill has cooled fully, ash should be cleared into a metal container — never plastic, as residual embers can persist for hours after the grill appears fully extinguished. Grills with removable ash pans simplify this process considerably; it is a feature worth prioritizing at purchase if year-round charcoal use is the plan. Grate Seasoning and Care: Cast iron grates benefit from post-cook seasoning — a light coat of high-smoke-point oil applied while the grate is still warm. This prevents rust formation and builds the surface layer that makes cast iron perform better over time. Stainless steel grates are lower maintenance but still benefit from a wipe-down while warm to remove fat deposits before they carbonize into harder-to-clean buildup. Exterior Paint and Rust Prevention: Most open-flame grills at the Bronco's price point use high-temperature exterior paint rather than powder coat. This paint can discolor or chip with heavy use, particularly at areas of peak heat exposure. Owners report that touching up exposed steel with high-temperature grill paint — widely available at hardware retailers — prevents rust progression and meaningfully extends the grill's service life. Cover and Storage: A properly fitted, heavy-duty cover is essential for year-round outdoor storage. Covers with ventilation grommets prevent moisture buildup beneath the cover, which is a more common rust accelerant than direct rain exposure. In regions with significant winter snowfall or ice, periodic removal of snow accumulation on the cover and occasional ventilation of the grill body prevents the moisture trap that accelerates interior corrosion. Safety Clearance and Surface Requirements: Open-flame charcoal and wood grills require meaningful clearance from combustible surfaces — structures, fences, overhead coverings, and furniture. Manufacturer guidance typically specifies a minimum distance from any combustible structure; treat that figure as a floor, not a target. Grilling on wooden decks requires particular caution with open-flame setups — falling embers and ash during post-cook cleaning present real ignition risk. A non-combustible surface pad under the grill is a practical safety measure for any deck installation.
The Decision Framework: Matching Grill to Cook
The most common mistake in this category is buying for the cook you imagine being rather than the one you actually are. Open-flame grills reward cooks who are genuinely willing to engage with fire management — they are not the right tool for someone who wants to set a temperature, walk away, and return to finished food. Before purchasing, work through these honest self-assessments: How often will you actually light charcoal? If the honest answer is fewer than once a week on average, the fuel-loading and ash-cleanup cycle of an open-flame setup may create enough friction to reduce how often you actually cook on it. A gas grill with excellent searing capability may produce better real-world results simply by being used more frequently. Do you have a fixed outdoor cooking space or a flexible one? Open-flame grills perform best in a site-optimized location with good clearance, nearby fuel storage, and stable footing. A setup that moves around or serves multiple locations favors the Camp Chef Explorer or a propane-based system. Are you typically cooking for two or for twenty? The Bronco's capacity is a genuine advantage at scale — multiple proteins across a full grate over live fire provides both cooking real estate and a level of dramatic, communal presentation that gas grills don't deliver. For a two-person household, that capacity can feel excessive and the fuel consumption relative to output less efficient than alternatives. What is the cooking experience itself worth to you? This is the question no specification sheet can answer honestly. For some cooks, managing a live fire is inseparable from the value of cooking outdoors — the ritual, the attention it demands, the skill that accumulates over seasons. For others, it is an obstacle between hunger and dinner. Neither answer is wrong. Being honest about which type of cook you are is what separates an open-flame grill that becomes the centerpiece of your outdoor cooking from an expensive piece of equipment that collects ash between reluctant uses.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Blackstone Bronco actually a Blackstone product, or is it just using the brand name?▾
The Bronco was developed and released under the Blackstone brand, but it represents a sharp departure from Blackstone's core product line of flat-top propane griddles. The Bronco is a charcoal-and-wood open-flame barrel grill — it shares no functional DNA with the flat-top units Blackstone built its reputation on. The Blackstone name reflects corporate ownership, not product continuity. Buyers expecting flat-top cooking convenience or propane ease of use should understand this distinction clearly before purchasing: the Bronco is a charcoal grill first, full stop.
Can you use wood only (no charcoal) in the Blackstone Bronco or similar open-flame grills?▾
Yes, but with important caveats. Most open-flame barrel grills including the Bronco can be run on hardwood splits or chunks as the sole fuel source. However, wood-only fires require more skill to manage — wood burns differently than charcoal, generates more visible flame and less consistent radiant heat in its early stages, and requires a longer burn-down period before conditions are suitable for cooking. Most experienced live-fire cooks use a charcoal base for heat consistency and add hardwood for smoke and flavor character. Pure wood fires are well-matched to experienced cooks who understand fire stages; beginners are better served starting with lump charcoal and introducing wood gradually.
What's the real difference between open-flame charcoal grilling and a standard charcoal kettle?▾
The core functional difference is grate height adjustability and the directness of fire access. A standard kettle grill places food at a fixed height above the coal bed, with cooking temperature managed through top and bottom vents. Open-flame grills like the Bronco and KUDU allow the cook to raise or lower the grate relative to the fire — which changes heat intensity more directly and responsively than vent adjustments allow. The KUDU's swing-out arm system goes further, enabling independent height and angle positioning per cooking zone. For cooks who take live-fire technique seriously, this adjustability is a meaningful functional difference from kettle cooking, not merely an aesthetic one.
Is the KUDU worth the price premium over the Blackstone Bronco?▾
For most backyard cooks, no. For a specific buyer profile, genuinely yes. The KUDU's multi-arm grate system, premium construction, and South African open-fire heritage make it the best available tool for cooks who actively practice gaucho-style or asado cooking, regularly prepare large-format proteins for groups, and want equipment built to outlast multiple seasons without maintenance compromise. If open-fire cooking is a central and consistent part of how you cook outdoors, the KUDU's premium reflects real additional value. If you want an open-flame grill primarily for weekend steaks and occasional larger cooks, the Bronco covers that use case at significantly lower cost.
Can you get a good sear from a gas open-flame grill, or do you need charcoal?▾
Gas open-flame grills — including open-grate burner zones like those on the Camp Chef Explorer — can produce solid sear marks and surface crust development, particularly at high output. What gas cannot replicate is the aromatic smoke character generated by fat dripping onto live coals and the flavor compounds contributed by burning hardwood. Owner communities consistently draw this distinction: gas searing is technically sound but comparatively flavor-flat against charcoal or wood-fire searing at equivalent surface temperatures. For cooks whose primary goal is crust development, gas is adequate. For cooks who want the complete live-fire flavor profile, charcoal or wood fire is not optional.
How do open-flame grills hold up in winter or year-round outdoor conditions?▾
Open-flame grills built to the standard of the Bronco, KUDU, and Oklahoma Joe's Firecraft can be maintained outdoors year-round with appropriate care. Cold ambient temperatures primarily affect ignition time and fuel consumption — both manageable with technique adjustments rather than equipment changes. The more critical consideration is rust prevention: heavy-gauge steel with properly maintained coating resists corrosion well, but chipped paint areas, pooled moisture under covers, and ash left in the fire bowl through wet seasons are the primary accelerants of premature degradation. A quality fitted cover with ventilation grommets and consistent post-cook ash clearing are the two habits that make the largest practical difference for year-round outdoor storage.
Get our best picks in your inbox
Weekly BBQ & grilling recommendations, no spam.