Best Open-Flame Grills Like the Blackstone for Backyard Cooking: Top Picks for Every Style and Budget
Our take
For backyard cooks who want flat-top versatility without giving up open-flame capability, the Blackstone 28-inch XL Omnivore Griddle with Hood is the most broadly useful starting point — it bridges griddle and grill cooking in a single station that most buyers can operate solo from day one. Buyers committed to authentic live-fire cooking over wood or charcoal should bypass the Omnivore and go directly to the KUDU Open Fire Grill, which is purpose-built for fire management and delivers a char character no propane-fired tool can replicate. The REDCAMP 2-in-1 Folding Camping Grill Grate is the clear answer for anyone who needs genuine open-flame cooking in a packable format.
Who it's for
- The Flat-Top Convert — a backyard cook moving on from a standard charcoal or gas grill who wants weeknight versatility (smash burgers, breakfast spreads, stir fry) without permanently sacrificing direct-flame capability. The Blackstone Omnivore format is built precisely for this transition.
- The Live-Fire Purist — someone who values the ritual and flavor depth of cooking over real wood or charcoal, wants hands-on grate height control, and is willing to climb the fire-management learning curve in exchange for restaurant-quality char on steaks and large cuts.
- The Camp-to-Backyard Dual User — a cook who grills at home on weekends but also heads to campsites, tailgates, or remote fire pits and needs a single piece of gear that covers both situations without requiring two separate purchases.
- The Outdoor Entertainer Upgrading from a Basic Gas Grill — someone who has outgrown a two-burner propane setup and wants a more capable, visually striking outdoor cooking station that can handle larger cuts, multiple proteins simultaneously, and sustained high heat output.
Who should look elsewhere
Buyers whose primary goal is low-and-slow smoking with minimal active tending are better served by a dedicated pellet grill or offset smoker — open-flame grills are optimized for high-heat searing and direct cooking, not extended multi-hour smokes that reward set-and-forget operation. Anyone working with a small patio or balcony should also measure footprint carefully before committing to any fixed-station option in this category, as the larger units are not easily repositioned once placed.
Pros
- Open-flame grills deliver direct, high-heat char that gas grills and flat-top griddles alone cannot replicate — this is the foundational flavor argument for the entire category
- Height-adjustable grate systems, most notably on the KUDU, give experienced cooks precise heat control without relying on burner dials or electronic temperature management
- The Blackstone Omnivore format uniquely bridges flat-top griddle and open-flame grate cooking in a single unit, eliminating the need for two separate pieces of equipment
- Stainless steel construction options offer a meaningful longevity advantage over painted or powder-coated steel in wet or coastal climates, with lower long-term maintenance burden
- Portable options like the REDCAMP grate make open-flame cooking accessible at campsites and tailgates without significant gear investment or logistical overhead
- Open-fire grills are mechanically simpler than gas or pellet grills — fewer electronic components means fewer failure points over seasons of use
Cons
- True open-flame cooking over wood or charcoal requires active fire management — it is not a set-and-forget format, and new users should expect a real learning curve before getting consistent results
- Larger fixed-station open-fire grills, including the KUDU and Santa Maria-style units, carry purchase prices that can exceed mid-range pellet grills — the investment is justified for committed live-fire cooks, not for occasional use
- Cooking surface temperature is less precise than gas or pellet formats — buyers who prioritize exact, repeatable temperature control will find this category genuinely frustrating
- Open-flame units without hoods, including the KUDU, are more exposed to wind and ambient weather variability, which can complicate heat management during a cook
- Post-cook cleanup after charcoal or wood-fired sessions is more involved than gas or electric alternatives — ash removal and grate scrubbing are ongoing commitments, not one-time tasks
- Some open-flame grill formats are prohibited in high fire-risk areas or HOA-governed neighborhoods — local rules and fire codes are worth verifying before purchasing any live-fire unit
Commission earned on purchases. Learn more
How it compares
Blackstone 28-inch XL Omnivore Griddle with Hood
The primary recommendation in this roundup. Unlike pure open-flame grills, the Omnivore gives backyard cooks a flat griddle surface and a grate cooking option with hood-retained heat in a single station — it is the most versatile entry point for buyers who are not ready to commit exclusively to live-fire cooking. The propane-powered system translates naturally for cooks coming from gas grills, and the 28-inch footprint is large enough for serious entertaining without requiring two people to set up. The honest limitation: it does not produce the wood-smoke flavor character of a charcoal or wood-burning grill. Best for cooks who want to cover the widest range of backyard cooking tasks with a single, manageable station.
KUDU Open Fire Grill
Where the Blackstone Omnivore prioritizes versatility and accessibility, the KUDU is built specifically for live open-fire cooking over wood or charcoal. Its height-adjustable grate arm is the defining feature — it allows a cook to raise the surface away from intense heat for slower finishing, or drop it directly over a hot ember bed for aggressive searing, mirroring the technique Argentine asado cooks and South African braai pitmasters have used for generations. Owner feedback consistently highlights the KUDU's build quality and the deep char character it produces on steaks and large-format cuts. The trade-offs are real: no flat-top capability, a higher price point, and a steeper learning curve than any propane-fired option. A strong choice for buyers who already know live-fire cooking is their primary backyard format — not for those who want it as an occasional feature.
REDCAMP 2-in-1 Folding Camping Grill Grate
Not a direct competitor to the Blackstone or KUDU in cooking output or station capability — this is a purpose-built portable campfire grate for buyers whose primary need is packability and flexibility across locations. The 304 stainless steel construction and folding design with carrying bag make it genuinely portable in a way no full-station grill can match. Owner feedback points to sturdy construction relative to its compact size, and the stainless material holds a meaningful durability advantage over painted-steel competitors at similar price points. The right buy for the dual-use camper or as a backyard fire-pit supplement; not the answer for buyers who need a primary cooking station.
TAGWOOD BBQ06SS Open Fire Grill
The TAGWOOD BBQ06SS represents the Santa Maria and Argentine-style open-fire tradition — a fixed-station, heavy-gauge steel construction grill built around cooking large cuts over wood or hardwood charcoal with a height-adjustable grate. Where the KUDU takes a more portable and tool-centered approach to live fire, the TAGWOOD is oriented toward a permanent or semi-permanent backyard setup with a broader cooking surface suited to entertaining at scale. The hand-crank grate adjustment mechanism is the primary heat control tool in this format, and its precision and smoothness are worth examining closely before purchasing — that mechanism directly determines how finely a cook can manage heat during a session. A strong choice for buyers who specifically want to build a dedicated outdoor cooking station around the Santa Maria tradition rather than a portable live-fire setup.
Why Open-Flame Grills Are Taking Over Backyards
The flat-top griddle wave that Blackstone popularized over the past several years produced an unexpected side effect: it introduced a generation of backyard cooks to the idea that their standard gas grill was not the only option — or even the best one. Once a cook experiences the Maillard reaction at scale on a flat griddle, or witnesses what a live-fire Argentine-style grill does to a ribeye, the question of 'what grill do I actually need' rarely goes back to a simple answer. Open-flame grills — whether live-fire charcoal stations, adjustable-grate wood-burning rigs, or hybrid griddle-and-grate combos — are gaining ground in the backyard segment because they solve something propane grills fundamentally cannot: they put fire back into the equation as an active cooking tool, not merely a heat source. The char development, the smoke integration, the instinctive heat management — these are design features, not inconveniences. And as outdoor kitchen culture has matured from a two-burner propane setup on a deck into a full cooking station mentality, buyers are no longer making a binary choice between gas and charcoal. They want both, or something genuinely different from either.
Open-Flame vs. Traditional Grill: What You Actually Need to Know
The most important distinction buyers miss is that 'open-flame grill' covers at least three meaningfully different product categories that get routinely collapsed into a single search result. First: flat-top griddle stations with open-flame or grate capability — the Blackstone Omnivore format. These are griddle-first tools that add grate or direct-flame options as a secondary mode. The cooking style is fast, high-output, and optimized for broad-surface cooking across multiple items simultaneously. Second: dedicated live-fire cooking systems over wood or charcoal with adjustable grates — the KUDU, Santa Maria, and Argentine-style grills. These are fire-management tools first. They reward cooks who understand ember beds, airflow, and the practical difference between a direct zone and an indirect zone built with wood. They automate nothing. Third: portable campfire grate systems — the REDCAMP category. These are utility items that extend fire-pit or campfire cooking to buyers who need packability above all else. They are not competing with full-station grills on performance. Traditional gas grills, for comparison, offer precise temperature control, fast startup, and minimal cleanup — but cannot produce the flavor depth of live-fire cooking or the flat-surface versatility of a griddle. The honest framing: if convenience and repeatability are the priority, a gas grill remains a legitimate choice. If flavor complexity, cooking ritual, or format versatility drive the decision, the open-flame category deserves serious consideration.
The Blackstone 28-inch XL Omnivore Griddle with Hood — The Most Practical Entry Point
The Blackstone Omnivore is the right starting point for the majority of buyers in this category because it resolves the most common source of buyer paralysis: 'Do I want a griddle or a grill?' The Omnivore format makes the question irrelevant. The flat-top surface handles smash burgers, quesadillas, eggs, and stir-fry. Swap to the grate configuration and the unit delivers direct-flame cooking suited to steaks, chicken thighs, and vegetables with actual grill marks and char development. The 28-inch footprint is meaningful — large enough for serious entertaining, but manageable as a solo setup. The included hood is not merely a weathering cover; used during cooking, it creates heat retention that expands technique range considerably, enabling indirect heat zones, cheese melts, and protein finishing that an open-top griddle cannot replicate. Owner feedback across the Omnivore line consistently points to reliable propane performance and a griddle surface that seasons well after proper break-in. The most frequently noted limitation is also the most honest one: the Omnivore is a propane-fired tool — it does not produce the live wood-smoke or charcoal flavor character that a KUDU or Santa Maria setup delivers. Buyers who specifically want that flavor profile need to look further down this list. For broad backyard versatility across the widest range of skill levels, the Omnivore is the most defensible Top Pick in this category.
Heavy-Duty Fixed Open-Flame Grills: KUDU and Santa Maria Styles
The KUDU Open Fire Grill is the most distinctive product in this comparison set because it operates from a fundamentally different premise than everything else here: the fire is the tool, and the grill is the framework built around it. The height-adjustable grate arm is the core mechanism — a cook raises the surface away from intense heat for slower finishing, or drops it directly over a hot ember bed for aggressive searing. This is how professional asado cooks and Argentine-style pitmasters have managed live-fire heat for generations, and the KUDU is the most accessible implementation of that philosophy available to North American backyard cooks. Owner reports consistently emphasize the KUDU's build quality and the learning curve it presents honestly. This is not a grill for someone who wants to turn a dial and walk away. For steak and large-format proteins specifically, the flavor profile owners describe — deep char, smoke integration, well-developed crust — is difficult to replicate with any gas or griddle format at any price point. The Santa Maria and Argentine style, represented in this category by the TAGWOOD BBQ06SS, takes the same live-fire philosophy and scales it toward a larger, fixed-station format. Santa Maria grilling — originating in Central California and built around red oak cooking with a lever or hand-crank-controlled grate — is a tradition, not just a technique. The TAGWOOD BBQ06SS targets buyers who want to build a dedicated outdoor cooking station around that tradition. Compared to the KUDU, it offers a larger cooking surface suited to feeding groups at scale, with lower portability and a higher commitment to a permanent setup location.
Portable and Camping Open-Flame Options
The REDCAMP 2-in-1 Folding Camping Grill Grate occupies a distinct category from the station grills above, but it belongs in this roundup because a meaningful segment of open-flame buyers need flexibility across contexts — not a fixed backyard station. Constructed from 304 stainless steel and designed to sit over a campfire, fire pit, or portable fire ring, the REDCAMP provides a stable cooking surface in environments where a full grill is impractical or impossible to transport. The folding design and carrying bag make it genuinely packable. Owner feedback highlights its sturdiness relative to its compact footprint, with the stainless construction noted as a clear durability advantage over cheaper painted-steel competitors in the same price tier. The honest framing: the REDCAMP is not competing with the KUDU or Blackstone on cooking output or technique range. It solves one specific problem — 'I want to cook over an open fire at a campsite or backyard fire pit without improvising a setup from scratch' — and it solves that problem well. For buyers who need a primary backyard cooking station, it is a supplement, not a standalone answer.
Construction and Durability: Stainless Steel vs. Powder-Coated Steel
Material choice is one of the most consequential long-term decisions in this category, and the market is not consistent about communicating what the trade-offs actually look like across seasons of outdoor exposure. Powder-coated steel — used on the Blackstone Omnivore body and across many entry-to-mid-tier open-flame grills — is durable under normal conditions but requires consistent cover use and maintenance in wet climates. Chipping and surface rust at connection points and seams are commonly reported among owners after extended outdoor exposure without covers. This does not make powder-coated steel a poor choice; it makes it a choice that demands corresponding user behavior to perform as intended. Stainless steel — found on the REDCAMP grate and in premium open-fire station grills — handles weather exposure meaningfully better without active rust prevention. The trade-off is cost: stainless steel construction at station-grill scale adds significantly to the purchase price. For buyers in high-humidity or coastal climates, or those who routinely leave gear exposed year-round, the stainless premium is defensible as a long-term cost-of-ownership calculation. Grate material warrants separate consideration. Cast iron grates retain heat well and produce excellent sear character but require active seasoning and rust prevention to maintain. Stainless steel grates are lower maintenance but do not hold or radiate heat as effectively. Neither is universally superior — the right choice depends on cooking style and honest assessment of how much maintenance the owner will actually perform.
Heat Control and Cooking Surface: What the Specs Actually Mean
Cooking surface area is typically the first specification buyers evaluate, and frequently the least useful one considered in isolation. A large flat-top griddle surface — like the Blackstone Omnivore's — delivers maximum value when cooking multiple items simultaneously at high volume: weekend breakfast for a crowd, smash burger sessions, high-output teppanyaki-style cooking. For live-fire grilling of individual steaks or whole birds, a smaller but well-designed grate surface over a properly built fire often outperforms a large griddle that never achieves consistent heat across its full area. Heat control architecture is the more important variable. The KUDU's physical grate height adjustment is a mechanical solution that experienced cooks can apply immediately and intuitively. The Blackstone Omnivore uses independently adjustable burner zones — a propane-logic approach that translates naturally for cooks migrating from gas grills. Neither system is inherently superior; they favor different cooking philosophies and experience levels. For Santa Maria-style grills like the TAGWOOD, the hand-crank height-adjustment mechanism is the primary heat control tool and the main differentiator between budget and premium units in that segment. The precision and smoothness of that crank mechanism directly determines how finely a cook can manage heat during a session — it is worth examining closely before purchasing, and owner feedback on this specific mechanism is a reliable signal of overall build quality.
Maintenance Reality: What Owning These Grills Actually Requires
The maintenance commitment for open-flame grills is consistently underestimated by first-time buyers — worth addressing plainly before any purchase decision. Flat-top griddle surfaces like the Blackstone Omnivore require seasoning: a process of building up polymerized oil layers that create a functional nonstick surface and protect against rust. This is not a one-time task. Seasoning degrades with use and requires periodic restoration. Owners who skip or rush the initial seasoning process frequently report sticking and surface corrosion; those who maintain it properly report surfaces that perform well for years without meaningful degradation. Live-fire charcoal and wood-burning grills — the KUDU and TAGWOOD — produce ash after every session that requires removal before the next cook. Grate cleaning after open-fire cooking is more intensive than after gas cooking because carbon buildup is heavier and more adhesive. The offset advantage: these grills are mechanically simple. No electronics, no igniters, no burner tubes — fewer components means fewer components to fail or require replacement over time. Portable stainless grates like the REDCAMP represent the lowest-maintenance option in this roundup: wipe clean, fold, store. Stainless construction means rust is not an active management concern the way it is with painted steel or un-seasoned cast iron.
Accessories That Actually Matter for Open-Flame Cooking
Equipment matters less than technique in open-flame cooking, but the right accessories can meaningfully close the skill gap — particularly for newer cooks working with live fire for the first time. Long-handled tools are non-negotiable for live-fire formats. Standard tongs that perform adequately on a propane grill are inadequate when managing a wood-fed fire in a KUDU or Santa Maria setup, where the heat source is less predictable and hand clearance is critical. Long-handled tongs — toward the longer end of the range commonly available — are the practical floor for full open-fire rigs; shorter options increase risk without meaningful benefit. A quality instant-read thermometer matters across every format in this category. Open-flame heat is less uniform than gas, which means relying on visual cues alone carries higher risk of over- or undercooking. Owner feedback across all live-fire grill categories consistently identifies thermometer use as the single most impactful tool for improving cook outcomes — more so than any grill accessory. For the Blackstone Omnivore and flat-top formats, a quality bench scraper and a round-edge spatula are the tools owners most frequently identify as technique-changing additions. A simple squirt bottle for water-based steam cooking on the flat top is also commonly cited as a low-cost, high-utility addition that unlocks techniques the standard tool kit doesn't support. For the REDCAMP and portable campfire category, a fireproof glove rated for high-contact-temperature environments is a safety-critical addition. Campfire grate cooking places hands and forearms closer to open flame than most backyard setups, and a standard oven mitt is not adequate protection.
Who Chose What and Why: Real Buyer Decision Patterns
Across owner communities and purchaser feedback for the products in this roundup, a few consistent decision patterns are worth surfacing for buyers still in the evaluation stage. The most common path to the Blackstone Omnivore: an owner already has a gas grill, wants to add flat-top cooking capability, and is drawn to the Omnivore specifically because it avoids an either/or commitment. The hood and grate option provide enough flexibility that many buyers report adopting it as their primary outdoor cooking station rather than a supplement to an existing grill — a transition they describe as permanent. The most common path to the KUDU: buyers who came from charcoal grills, grew frustrated with the limitations of kettle geometry for live-fire heat management, and specifically wanted physical height control over an open fire. A notable segment are buyers who researched Argentine asado or South African braai traditions and identified the KUDU as the most accessible entry point into that cooking style available in the North American market. The most common path to the REDCAMP: dual-use buyers — people who camp regularly and also cook at a backyard fire pit — who wanted a single versatile grate rather than separate campfire and backyard gear. Price accessibility is consistently a factor in this decision; the REDCAMP's entry-level price point relative to full-station grills makes it a low-risk first purchase for buyers new to open-fire cooking who want to build confidence before committing to a larger setup.
Price Tiers and Value: Where to Spend and Where to Save
The open-flame grill category spans a wide price range, and the value logic is not linear. Spending more does not reliably mean getting more of what matters for a given buyer's specific use case. At the accessible end, the REDCAMP Folding Camping Grill Grate — available at time of publication for under $50 across most retailers — is the clearest value proposition in the category for its specific use case. If portability and campfire cooking are the primary needs, there is no reason to spend more. The Blackstone 28-inch XL Omnivore with Hood sits in the mid-range for this category (at time of publication, typically positioned in the $300–$400 range, with frequent promotional pricing). Given its dual flat-top and grate capability, the value argument is strong for buyers who would otherwise need to purchase a griddle and a grill separately to cover the same cooking ground. The KUDU Open Fire Grill represents a premium investment for this category (at time of publication, typically positioned above $500 at retail). That premium is justified for buyers who will actively use the live-fire format as their primary cooking mode — the build quality and grate adjustment system are meaningfully above budget open-fire competitors. It is not justified for buyers who want live-fire capability as an occasional or aspirational feature rather than a regular practice. The TAGWOOD BBQ06SS and Santa Maria-style grills occupy a similar or higher price tier than the KUDU and are most defensible as investments for buyers building a permanent or semi-permanent outdoor cooking station specifically around Argentine or Santa Maria-style cooking. As a secondary or occasional-use grill, the price-to-utility ratio weakens considerably.
Final Picks and Decision Framework
The right open-flame grill is not universal — it depends on how central live-fire cooking is to the buyer's actual use pattern, not the aspirational version of it. For the broadest range of backyard cooks: the Blackstone 28-inch XL Omnivore Griddle with Hood. It handles the most common backyard cooking tasks across the widest skill range, and its hybrid griddle-plus-grate format means buyers are not locked into a single cooking mode or technique set. For buyers who know they want authentic live-fire cooking over wood or charcoal as their primary backyard format: the KUDU Open Fire Grill. It is the most purpose-built and operator-rewarding option in this roundup, and its adjustable-grate system has no meaningful equivalent in this price tier. For buyers building a dedicated Santa Maria or Argentine-style outdoor cooking station for entertaining at scale: the TAGWOOD BBQ06SS deserves direct evaluation alongside the KUDU. The key differentiator is cooking surface scale and whether a permanent station or a portable setup better fits the available space and use pattern. For buyers who need a portable, packable open-fire cooking solution for camping, tailgating, or fire-pit use: the REDCAMP Folding Camping Grill Grate is the most practical and cost-effective answer in this category, without meaningful competition at its price point. The insight that unifies all of these picks: open-flame cooking rewards investment in learning at least as much as investment in equipment. A buyer who understands fire management will consistently get more from a KUDU than someone who spends the same amount on a feature-heavy gas grill they never fully learn to operate. Buy for the cooking you will actually do — not the cooking you imagine doing on the day you place the order.
Frequently asked questions
What's the main difference between an open-flame grill like the KUDU and a flat-top griddle like the Blackstone Omnivore?▾
Open-flame grills expose food directly to live fire — whether wood or charcoal — and require active fire management to control heat zones and char development. Flat-top griddles like the Blackstone use a solid cooking surface with burners underneath, making them easier to control and better suited to cooking multiple items at different temperatures simultaneously. The Blackstone Omnivore bridges both styles by offering a flat-top surface plus an open-flame grate option, making it a practical entry point for buyers who want griddle versatility without fully committing to fire tending. If authentic wood-fire cooking and direct flame char are the primary goal, the KUDU is purpose-built for that experience in a way the Omnivore is not.
Can I manage an open-flame grill like the KUDU or TAGWOOD solo, or do I need a second person to help with the fire?▾
Open-flame grills require active attention to fire placement, ember management, and heat zoning — tasks that are manageable solo once a cook develops the rhythm, but are less forgiving than gas grills during the learning phase. The Blackstone 28-inch Omnivore is designed for solo operation without strain, with its flat-top layout and independent burner controls. If genuine open-flame cooking is the goal but a full fire-management setup feels like too steep an entry point, the Blackstone Bronco Open Flame Grill offers a middle ground with simpler operation than a wood-fired open-fire rig. For solo cooks who prioritize ease alongside capability, the Blackstone lineup is a stronger fit than dedicated live-fire grills.
I camp frequently and need something portable. Are there open-flame options that actually pack down small?▾
The REDCAMP 2-in-1 Folding Camping Grill Grate is specifically built for portability — it folds compact, travels in a carrying bag, and delivers legitimate open-flame cooking without the footprint or weight of a station grill. Most other open-flame grills in this lineup are stationary backyard units that do not pack down meaningfully. If camping is the primary use case, the REDCAMP is the clear choice. If a substantial backyard setup and occasional portable cooking are both required, pairing a permanent grill with a collapsible campfire grate is a more realistic approach than expecting a single unit to excel at both.
If I want traditional charcoal or wood-fire cooking with live flame, which grill should I choose?▾
The KUDU Open Fire Grill is purpose-built for authentic wood and charcoal cooking with direct flame management — it is the right choice when live-fire cooking is the core interest and the buyer is comfortable tending fire actively. The TAGWOOD BBQ06SS is the alternative to consider for buyers who want a larger, fixed-station Santa Maria-style setup suited to cooking for groups. Both reward cooks who value the hands-on nature of fire control and want genuine char development. If wood-fire capability is desired alongside the flexibility of easier temperature management for everyday cooking, the Pit Boss 850 Pellet Grill with Open Flame Zone or the Smoke Hollow 6500 Combination Grill offer hybrid functionality — though both involve greater complexity and a larger footprint commitment than a single-purpose live-fire grill.
Get our best picks in your inbox
Weekly BBQ & grilling recommendations, no spam.